Aventurine vs cFIREsim and FIREproof

cFIREsim is a free simulator that runs your retirement through every stretch of market history since 1871, and FIREproof is its paid successor from the same creator, adding taxes and account-by-account planning. Aventurine Planner is a visual plan builder for budgets, debt and goals at any stage of life, from your first paycheck to retirement.

cFIREsim and FIREproof

cFIREsim is one of the original FIRE calculators and has run tens of millions of simulations. It takes your retirement plan and replays it through every historical period since 1871, so you can see how it would have fared in the best and worst markets on record. It handles Social Security, pensions, a mix of stocks, bonds, gold and cash, and spending plans like Guyton-Klinger and variable percentage withdrawal, and it is free.

These days its creator is focused on FIREproof, which runs the same market history with federal and state taxes applied account by account. The free version saves one simulation; FIREproof Pro, at $10 a month or $89 a year, adds Monte Carlo, Roth conversions, tax-optimized withdrawals, a cash flow Sankey and side-by-side comparisons. The downside of both is how they feel to use. They are basic, form-heavy tools whose interfaces are well behind most other planners today: you fill in fields, press run and read the charts, with little to guide you along the way.

If you are planning an early or traditional retirement, are comfortable working through plain forms, and want your plan tested against real market history with the tax detail to match, cFIREsim and FIREproof are a good fit.

cFIREsim's Portfolio Over Time chart: one colored line for each 30-year retirement starting from 1871 onward, showing a $1,000,000 portfolio rising as high as $6,000,000 in good periods and falling to zero in a few poor ones.

Aventurine

Aventurine is a financial planner built around being easy to use and, most importantly, flexible. It takes the intimidating task of planning your financial future and turns it into something visual and approachable

The software is made for every stage of life, not just retirement. You can build your first budget, plan your way through college, save up for your first car, get ready to rent or buy your first home, and model retirement when it's on the horizon. Plans are open-ended, so you can plug in your own rates, try different account structures, and explore different paths to where you want to go. This flexibility is where Aventurine shines, backed by rich, visual reports at a more approachable price.

If you are someone who is just starting out, working toward a big milestone, or simply wants to explore how different choices shape your future without getting buried in forms, Aventurine is an excellent fit.

Aventurine Planner's canvas showing the Starting a Family plan: two incomes feed two checking accounts, which pay into a 401(k), joint savings, a college fund and an investment account, and cover a mortgage, insurance, food, household and hobbies, with a 20-year timeline below.
A Sankey diagram of a First Job plan over five years: a $100,000 college job flows into spending on food, video games and personal care, income tax withholding, and checking and savings accounts.
Three goals checked against the plan: Save 100k met early, Save 5k met 8 months late, and Make 5 Million never met, at 36%.

Side by side

  • Included
  • Partly
  • Not offered
Aventurine cFIREsim & FIREproof
Planning
Visual drag-and-drop builderYesNo
Plans for any stage of lifeYesNo
Easy for beginnersYesNo
Budgets, debt and savingsYesPartly
Custom goalsYesNo
Compare plans side by sideYesYes
Cash flow and Sankey chartsYesYes
Historical backtestingNoYes
Monte Carlo simulationsNoYes
Withdrawal strategiesNoYes
Detailed tax modelingPartlyYes
CSV exportYesYes
Privacy
No bank linking neededYesYes
End-to-end encryptionYesNo
Never sells your dataYesYes
Price
Free to tryYesYes
Monthly$7.99/mo$10/mo
Yearly$74.99/yr$89/yr
Plans for advisorsNoYes

cFIREsim and FIREproof details checked November 2026 from cfiresim.com, its About page and FIREproof's pricing page. cFIREsim is free with no accounts. FIREproof's free Basic plan saves one simulation; Monte Carlo, comparisons, Roth conversions, the Taxes tab, the cash flow Sankey, the itemized budget and spreadsheet export are in FIREproof Pro, priced here. Prices and features change, so check there before you decide. cFIREsim and FIREproof are trademarks of their owner; Aventurine is not affiliated with them.

Weighing more than these two? See the best cFIREsim alternatives, compared side by side.

Try Aventurine For Free

Try the demo in your browser. No account, no card.