cFIREsim alternatives
cFIREsim and its paid successor FIREproof test your retirement against every market since 1871, through plain forms. Here are five alternatives, what each one is best at, and what it costs.
Why people look for a cFIREsim and FIREproof alternative
cFIREsim and FIREproof run thorough historical simulations, with taxes in FIREproof. The common complaint is how they feel to use: form-heavy interfaces that are well behind most planners today, with little guidance along the way. You fill in fields, press run and read the charts.
They also focus on retirement alone, so budgets, debt and goals earlier in life sit outside them.
When cFIREsim and FIREproof is still the right choice
If you are comfortable with plain forms and want your plan tested against every market period since 1871, with tax detail in FIREproof, they remain a solid choice.
At a glance
| Planner | Best for | Price | Bank linking | Simulations | End-to-end encryption |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Historical simulations with tax detail, for early retirees | cFIREsim free; FIREproof Pro $10/mo or $89/yr | None needed | Historical, plus Monte Carlo in FIREproof Pro | No | |
| Visual planning for budgets, debt and goals at any stage of life | $7.99/mo or $74.99/yr, free demo | None, by design | None | Yes | |
| Stress-testing a retirement withdrawal strategy | Free, supported by donations | None needed | Historical backtesting | No | |
| Detailed retirement and tax planning, close to retirement | $129/yr, free to try | None needed | Monte Carlo and historical backtesting | No | |
| Social Security, Roth conversion and retirement tax decisions | $14/mo or $168/yr for PlannerPlus, free tier | Optional | Monte Carlo, in PlannerPlus | No | |
| Free, automatic tracking of every linked account | Free; wealth management 0.89%/yr of assets | Built around it | Monte Carlo | No |
Details checked November 2026 from each company's own pricing and product pages. Prices and features change, so check there before you decide. All product names are trademarks of their owners; Aventurine is not affiliated with any of them.
1. Aventurine Planner
Best for: visual planning for budgets, debt and goals at any stage of life
- Price
- $7.99/mo or $74.99/yr, free demo
- Bank linking
- None, by design
- End-to-end encryption
- Yes
Aventurine Planner is a visual plan builder. You lay out your income, accounts, debts and spending on a canvas, link them together, and it projects your net worth month by month, with cash flow and Sankey charts, side-by-side plan comparisons and goals checked against the plan.
It is made for every stage of life, not just retirement: a first budget, college, a first car or home, a family, and retirement when it comes into view. You enter everything by hand, nothing links to your bank, and plans are encrypted end to end, so only you can read them. It does not run Monte Carlo simulations or detailed tax projections.
2. FI Calc
Best for: stress-testing a retirement withdrawal strategy
- Price
- Free, supported by donations
- Bank linking
- None needed
- End-to-end encryption
- No
FI Calc answers one question very well: if you retire with this portfolio and spend this much, how would it have held up through every stretch of market history?
You choose from about a dozen withdrawal strategies, such as Guyton-Klinger, variable percentage withdrawal or a CAPE-based rule, and it shows success rates, spending and ending balances across every historical period. It is free and runs in your browser with no account needed. It does not cover budgets, debt or goals.
3. ProjectionLab
Best for: detailed retirement and tax planning, close to retirement
- Price
- $129/yr, free to try
- Bank linking
- None needed
- End-to-end encryption
- No
ProjectionLab is one of the most popular retirement planners, and a polished one. You fill in its forms by hand, with no bank logins, and it builds a colourful projection of your net worth with life events, plan comparisons, cash flow charts, Monte Carlo simulations and backtesting.
Its precise tax modelling is its biggest strength, and it is most useful for people close to retirement who live in one of the countries it supports. It costs $129 a year, with no monthly plan, and it also sells plans for advisors.
4. Boldin
Best for: social Security, Roth conversion and retirement tax decisions
- Price
- $14/mo or $168/yr for PlannerPlus, free tier
- Bank linking
- Optional
- End-to-end encryption
- No
Boldin, formerly NewRetirement, walks you through your finances one section at a time and turns them into a dashboard of net worth, projections and a chance of success for your retirement.
Its paid PlannerPlus tier is where it earns its place: Monte Carlo simulations, federal and state tax projections, and explorers for when to claim Social Security and how much to convert to a Roth. You can link accounts to keep balances current, and Boldin sells a one-time plan review with a fee-only advisor.
5. Empower
Best for: free, automatic tracking of every linked account
- Price
- Free; wealth management 0.89%/yr of assets
- Bank linking
- Built around it
- End-to-end encryption
- No
Empower, formerly Personal Capital, offers a free dashboard that pulls your linked bank, credit card, investment and retirement accounts into one place and tracks net worth, cash flow and investments automatically.
Its free retirement planner runs Monte Carlo simulations against your real balances and checks your portfolio for fees. It is free because it leads into Empower's paid wealth management, so with a large enough portfolio, expect an advisor to get in touch.